🌍 Quranic Cosmology: Flat Earth Flub?

Thesis:
Islam pitches the Quran as God’s eternal word, a cosmic masterclass straight from the top (15:9). But when it talks skies and earth, it’s a 7th-century flop—sun setting in mud, earth flat as a rug, no clue about orbits or stars. Early Muslims took it straight; modern spins dodge it. This ain’t divine science—it’s Muhammad’s eyeball guess, and it sinks the “perfect revelation” myth hard.

---

1. Sun Sets in a Muddy Mess

• Quran 18:86—Dhul-Qarnayn finds “the sun setting in a dark, muddy spring”. Literal as it gets—“reached the place”. Early tafsir like Ibn Kathir? Straight-up: sun dips into a swamp, done. Modern apologists twist—“it looked like that”—nah, text says “found”, not “seemed”. “God’s word or desert mirage?”—15:9’s “truth” is bleeding already.

2. Earth’s a Flat Carpet

• Quran 71:19—“And Allah has made the earth for you as a carpet spread out”. 88:20—“laid flat”. Arabic bistatan—spread flat, no curve. Tafsir al-Jalalayn? Earth’s a plane, mate. “No sphere, no spin”—7th-century Bedouins nod, but science laughs. “Divine map or Muhammad’s mat?”—Quran’s stuck in the sand.

3. Sky’s a Solid Roof

• Quran 21:32—“We made the sky a protected ceiling”. 2:22—“a canopy”. Early takes (Tabari)—physical dome, holds rain, stops collapse. “Solid lid”—no hint of space, just a tent over the flats. Stars? 67:5—“lamps” to chuck at devils. “Cosmic fairy tale”—15:9’s “guarded” word flops against Galileo.

4. No Orbits, No Clue

• Sun and moon? Quran 36:40—“each swims in a falak”—orbit, sure, but 21:33 says “night and day chase each other”—earth’s still, skies spin. “Geocentric junk”—no heliocentric nod, no earth’s tilt. Ptolemy’s 2nd-century playbook, not God’s. “Muhammad’s sky, not Allah’s”—Quran’s blind to the real cosmos.

5. Early Muslims Bought It—Modern Ones Squirm

• Ibn Abbas, Ibn Kathir—“flat earth, sun sets in mud”—no metaphor, just fact for them. Post-Copernicus? Apologists scramble—“poetic”, “perspective”—bull. Quran’s not vague—“spread out”, “found it setting”. “Retrofit dodge”—7th-century literalists expose the fix. “Timeless? Try time-locked”.

6. Biblical Contrast: Less Dumb, Still Old

• Genesis—earth’s a flat disc, waters above (1:6-8). But Quran doubles down—mud springs, devil-lamps—“extra dumb”. NT? Silent on cosmology—“no cosmic egg to crack”. Quran’s bold and wrong—“divine flub, not divine flex”. 15:9’s “perfect” takes a beating.

---

🔍 Verdict: Quran’s Cosmic Crash

Strip it bare: Quran’s world is flat, sky’s a roof, sun’s a swamp-diver—straight out of Muhammad’s desert goggles. Early tafsirs lock it literal; modern spins can’t save it. “No divine science”—15:9’s “guarded revelation” flops when it’s clueless on stars, orbits, reality.

• Evidence: Quran 18:86, 71:19, Ibn Kathir—“their own words”—cosmic fail on display.
• Logic: Eternal truth vs. 7th-century guess—“self-sunk”—Quran’s a relic, not a reveal.
• Vibe: “Wrecking ball”—this ain’t wisdom, it’s a worldview stuck in the dirt.

Islam’s “perfect book”? Nah—it’s a cosmic clown show, bleeding from its own backward cuts. Another fatal stab to the myth.