Can Islamic Salvation Be Trusted If Allah Guides and Misguides Arbitrarily?

The Qur’an repeatedly asserts that Allah guides whom He wills and misguides whom He wills. This doctrine, rooted in divine volition rather than human agency, raises an unavoidable theological question: Can salvation in Islam be trusted? If guidance depends not on belief, effort, or righteousness—but rather on an unknowable divine whim—then the path to salvation is not a moral journey, but a gamble.

---

The Core Verses: Divine Will Overrides Human Will

Qur’an 16:93 – "...He misguides whom He wills and guides whom He wills."

Qur’an 6:110 – "We will turn their hearts and their eyes away [from the truth], just as they refused to believe in it the first time."

Qur’an 2:7 – "Allah has set a seal upon their hearts and upon their hearing, and over their vision is a veil."

These verses make no room for neutral observers or sincere seekers who are merely mistaken. Instead, the text portrays a preemptive divine action that determines belief and disbelief.

---

Theological Fatalism: Guidance Is Not Earned

According to classical Sunni theology—especially the Ash‘ari school—human beings do not create their own actions.

• Al-Ash‘ari taught that Allah creates both the actions and the will to act.

• Imam al-Ghazali stated: "The act of the servant is created by God, yet acquired by the servant.”

• Tafsir al-Kabir by Fakhr al-Din al-Razi affirms that guidance is a gift Allah gives only to those He chooses, not something anyone can earn.

This raises an unsettling possibility: Even if you do everything right, you may still be misled—because Allah did not will your salvation.

---

Is This Mercy or Arbitrary Judgment?

Islamic theology also affirms that Allah is the Most Merciful (Ar-Rahman, Ar-Rahim). But how does divine mercy align with the idea that:

• Some people are created for hell (per hadiths such as Sahih Muslim 2662a).

• He seals hearts before people have the chance to believe.

• He punishes people for disbelief He Himself caused.

This is not justice. This is divine favoritism cloaked in mystery.

---

Apologetic Loopholes and Their Collapse

Some Islamic apologists attempt to soften this by arguing:

• “People are only misguided after rejecting the truth.”

• “Allah’s guidance depends on people’s sincerity.”

However, these claims directly contradict explicit Qur’anic statements where Allah acts first to misguide:

• Q 6:110 – He turns hearts and eyes before faith can take root.

• Q 14:4 – “He misguides whom He wills and guides whom He wills.” There’s no mention of prior rejection.

The text is not conditional—it is declarative.

---

Uncertainty of Salvation in Islam

Islam offers no assurance of salvation even for the devout:

Sahih al-Bukhari 6098 – “By Allah, even though I am the Apostle of Allah, yet I do not know what Allah will do to me.”

If Muhammad himself was unsure of his fate, how can any Muslim be confident?

Add to this the idea that Allah may guide or misguide anyone arbitrarily, and you have a deeply insecure spiritual system—one in which all deeds, beliefs, and intentions are meaningless unless pre-approved by divine decree.

---

Conclusion: A Salvation System Based on Divine Caprice

The Islamic concept of guidance paints a disturbing picture:

• Allah controls who believes and who doesn’t.

• He seals hearts and blinds eyes before choices are made.

• He punishes people for their disbelief—even when He caused it.

This isn’t a system of salvation. It’s a system of predetermined judgment with no transparency, no appeal, and no assurance. In such a scheme, trust in salvation is misplaced—because the one who saves also chooses to damn without explanation.