Islam’s Preservation Dilemma: Why the Qur'an Self-Destructs
Introduction
Islam claims to be the final, perfect revelation of the God of Abraham — the culmination of a long series of divine messages, beginning with the Torah given to Moses and the Gospel given to Jesus. The Qur'an insists it confirms these earlier scriptures and portrays Muhammad as part of their prophetic lineage.
But a devastating dilemma haunts this narrative, one from which no Muslim escape is possible:
Either the Torah and Gospel are preserved and true, or Islam collapses.
Or the Torah and Gospel are corrupted, and Islam still collapses.
This is the noose the Qur'an tightens around its own neck.
The Foundations of the Dilemma
1. Allah Vows to Preserve His Revelation
The Qur'an boldly declares:
"Indeed, We have sent down the Dhikr (Reminder), and surely We will preserve it."
— Qur'an 15:9
Note: the Arabic word Dhikr is not restricted to the Qur'an. It broadly refers to Allah’s revealed messages, including prior scriptures. There are no pronouns specifying Muhammad, no limitations. Allah promises to protect His words — period.
Further, the Qur'an asserts:
"Perfect are the words of your Lord in truth and justice. None can change His words."
— Qur'an 6:115
The message is clear: Allah's revelations are incorruptible.
2. The Qur'an Acknowledges the Torah and Gospel as Divine
Allah explicitly claims responsibility for sending down the Torah and Gospel:
"He has sent down upon you, [O Muhammad], the Book in truth, confirming what was before it. And He revealed the Torah and the Gospel."
— Qur'an 3:3
Thus, from an Islamic standpoint:
The Torah and Gospel were sent by Allah.
They are part of the Dhikr Allah promises to protect.
3. Islam Explicitly Rejects Christian Theology
Yet the Qur'an fiercely condemns Christians for worshiping Jesus as divine:
"They have certainly disbelieved who say, 'Allah is the Messiah, the son of Mary.'"
— Qur'an 5:72
"They have certainly disbelieved who say, 'Allah is the third of three.'"
— Qur'an 5:73
Thus, according to the Qur'an:
Worshiping Jesus as God = disbelief (kufr).
Trinitarian theology = falsehood.
The Crushing Contradiction
Here's the brutal logic:
| Step | Argument |
|---|---|
| 1 | Allah promises to preserve His revelations (Torah, Gospel, Qur'an). |
| 2 | Allah revealed the Torah and Gospel. |
| 3 | The Torah and Gospel, as we have them, present Jesus as divine. |
| 4 | Islam rejects Jesus’ divinity as falsehood and disbelief. |
| 5 | Therefore, either: |
| 5a | The Torah and Gospel were corrupted, and Allah failed to preserve them — making the Qur'an's preservation promise false. |
| 5b | The Torah and Gospel are preserved, and Islam’s theology about Jesus is false. |
| 6 | In both cases, Islam self-destructs. |
This is an airtight, double-edged sword.
There is no Islamic way out.
Muslim Apologist Escape Tactics — and Why They Fail
Desperate to avoid this fatal trap, Muslim apologists invent excuses. Here’s why each one collapses:
❌ "Only Parts of the Torah and Gospel Were Corrupted!"
Claim:
Some verses remain true; others were altered.
Fatal Flaws:
Allah vowed full preservation, not partial. (Qur'an 15:9, 6:115)
No Qur'anic guidance distinguishes "good" verses from "bad" ones.
Qur'an 5:47 commands Christians to judge by the Gospel without qualification.
→ If only parts were valid, Allah’s command was reckless.
This “partial corruption” theory is pure fantasy without Qur'anic support.
❌ "The Qur'an Refers to a Heavenly Torah and Gospel!"
Claim:
Allah speaks only of original, heavenly versions, not earthly scriptures.
Fatal Flaws:
Qur'an directly addresses Jews and Christians about the books they physically possessed.
(e.g., Qur'an 5:43 — "They have the Torah wherein is Allah’s judgment.")If the Torah and Gospel existed only in heaven, commanding earthly people to follow them is absurd.
Muhammad’s appeals would be meaningless if no real Torah or Gospel existed among people.
This "heavenly scripture" dodge is theological suicide.
❌ "The Torah and Gospel Were Abrogated by the Qur'an!"
Claim:
Allah canceled previous revelations with the Qur'an.
Fatal Flaws:
Abrogation ≠ Corruption.
Canceling a law doesn't mean it becomes false.Timing problem:
Qur'an commands Christians during Muhammad’s time to follow the Gospel (5:47).Logical problem:
If the Torah and Gospel were valid during Muhammad’s mission, they couldn’t have been massively corrupted beforehand.
This excuse dodges nothing.
❌ "Tahrif Means Misinterpretation, Not Textual Corruption!"
Claim:
Jews and Christians merely misinterpreted their scriptures.
Fatal Flaws:
Qur'an 2:79 condemns textual fabrication:
"Woe to those who write the Book with their own hands and say, 'This is from Allah.'"Qur'an 5:13 speaks of "distorting words from their places" — implying deliberate textual tampering.
Even if misinterpretation were the issue, the Qur'an still treats existing Torah and Gospel texts as binding.
This semantic quibble collapses under its own weight.
The Deeper Implications
1. Allah is Incompetent or Deceptive.
Either Allah could not protect His own revelations (incompetence) or allowed humanity to be misled for centuries (deception). In both cases, he is not the all-wise, all-powerful God he claims to be.
2. Islam Is Not an Abrahamic Faith.
If Jews and Christians worshipped a fundamentally different God, then Islam cannot claim legitimate Abrahamic descent.
→ Islam worships a different, newly invented deity.
3. Muhammad Misunderstood or Lied About the Scriptures.
If the Torah and Gospel did not match the Qur'an’s theology, Muhammad either:
Did not know their real contents (ignorance),
Or he deliberately misrepresented them (deception).
Either way, his prophethood is disqualified.
4. Trust in Qur'anic Preservation Is Baseless.
If earlier revelations could be corrupted despite Allah’s promises, there is no logical reason to trust that the Qur'an itself is preserved.
Conclusion
The Qur'an sets a trap for itself by affirming the Torah and Gospel as divine and promising their preservation. But by rejecting the core teachings of the Torah and Gospel — particularly the divinity of Christ — the Qur'an guarantees its own downfall.
There is no escape:
If the Torah and Gospel are corrupted, Allah is a liar.
If the Torah and Gospel are preserved, Islam is a lie.
Either way, the Qur'an collapses under the weight of its own contradictions.
Islam's claim to divine truth is not just weak — it is self-obliterating.
No comments:
Post a Comment