Thursday, April 24, 2025

10 More Dawah Claims That Self-Destruct

They’re Meant to Defend Islam — But They Collapse It Instead


🧠 #1: “There Are No Contradictions in the Qur’an.”

❌ Reality:

  • Then why does Surah 4:82 exist as a built-in test?

  • And how do you explain 6 vs 8 days of creation, or the first Muslim being 3 different people?

πŸ“Œ The moment a contradiction appears, the book fails its own divine test.


🧠 #2: “Islam Was the First and Final Religion.”

❌ Reality:

  • Then why does the Qur’an say the Torah and Gospel were also from Allah?

  • Why is there a 600-year prophetic gap between Jesus and Muhammad?

  • Where is the evidence of “Islam” as a religion before the 7th century?

πŸ“Œ This is historical revisionism, not revelation.


🧠 #3: “Muhammad Is Prophesied in the Bible.”

❌ Reality:

  • No verse explicitly names him — and retrofitting vague phrases like “Comforter” is pure eisegesis.

  • If the Bible was corrupted, how can it be used to prove Muhammad?

πŸ“Œ You can’t validate your prophet using a book you also call corrupted.


🧠 #4: “Early Muslims Memorized the Qur’an Perfectly.”

❌ Reality:

  • Then why did Abu Bakr order a written compilation because memorizers were dying?

  • Why did Uthman burn other Qur’ans?

  • Why did Ibn Mas’ud and Ubayy disagree on chapters?

πŸ“Œ Perfect memorization doesn’t need a cleanup crew or a bonfire.


🧠 #5: “The Qur’an Has Been Preserved Word-for-Word Since Muhammad.”

❌ Reality:

  • Not when there are different Arabic Qur’ans in use today (Hafs, Warsh, etc.).

  • Not when verses are missing (like stoning and breastfeeding).

  • Not when the first complete codex is centuries late.

πŸ“Œ The claim dies under historical scrutiny.


🧠 #6: “Islam Elevated Women.”

❌ Reality:

  • Women are half a witness, half an heir, and can be beaten (4:34).

  • Muhammad married a 6-year-old.

  • Female prophets? None.

πŸ“Œ “Better than Jahiliyyah” doesn’t mean “good.” It means less bad.


🧠 #7: “Islam Promotes Peace.”

❌ Reality:

  • Then why did Muhammad lead over 80 battles and raids?

  • Why does Surah 9:29 command fighting non-Muslims “until they pay jizya in humiliation”?

  • Why is apostasy punished by death?

πŸ“Œ Peace isn’t the absence of resistance — it’s the suppression of it.


🧠 #8: “The Qur’an Is a Linguistic Miracle.”

❌ Reality:

  • Eloquence is not evidence — otherwise Shakespeare was a prophet.

  • If poetic beauty = divinity, that’s subjective and self-refuting.

  • Other books in Arabic have matched or exceeded its structure.

πŸ“Œ It’s a literary claim, not a supernatural one.


🧠 #9: “Islam Is Growing — That Proves It’s True.”

❌ Reality:

  • Popularity doesn’t equal truth — or TikTok would be divine.

  • Christianity grew faster in its first 300 years — under persecution.

  • Islam grows due to birth rates, not conversions.

πŸ“Œ Islam is demographically expanding, not theologically thriving.


🧠 #10: “Islam Is the Only Religion with Unchanged Scripture.”

❌ Reality:

  • The Torah and Gospel have manuscript chains longer and older than the Qur’an.

  • Qur’anic manuscripts have corrections, marginal notes, missing verses, and multiple versions.

  • Even Muslim scholars admit variant readings and recensions.

πŸ“Œ The “unchanged Qur’an” is a modern myth — not a historical fact.


πŸ’₯ Final Shot

“These Dawah lines sound impressive — until you examine them.
Then they implode under their own weight.

They're not arguments — they're marketing slogans.
And truth doesn’t need slogans to stand.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Islam and the Morality of Sex Slavery Why Qur’an 4:24 Is a Problem That Cannot Be Explained Away When Divine Revelation Permits Owning and ...