Wednesday, April 23, 2025

👁‍🗨 Why No One Ever Saw Jibril

The Problem with Private Revelations in Islam


🧭 Introduction: The Foundation No One Could Verify

Islam claims that the Qur’an is the literal word of God, revealed to Muhammad by the angel Jibril (Gabriel) over a span of 23 years.

Sounds grand — until you ask the one question no one wants to answer:

Who actually witnessed any of these revelations?

The uncomfortable answer?

❌ No one.
❌ Not once.
❌ Not ever.

Every single Qur’anic revelation — all 6,000+ verses — was a private experience.
No public audience.
No independent verification.
No eyewitnesses.

That’s not divine communication — that’s unverifiable hearsay.


📜 What Islam Claims

  • The angel Jibril appeared to Muhammad in caves, on journeys, even in his home.

  • He conveyed the very words of Allah, verbatim.

  • These revelations were memorized or written down by Muhammad’s followers.

But here’s what never happened:

  • No one saw Jibril.

  • No one heard the words being revealed.

  • No one confirmed the event in real time.

Even Muhammad’s own closest companions — Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Ali — never saw what he saw.

That’s not revelation. That’s a man claiming invisible experiences no one else can confirm.


🚨 The Dangerous Implication

If someone came today and said:

“An angel appears to me in private and gives me messages from God... you just have to believe me.”

What would you say?

Exactly.

You’d call it:

  • Delusion

  • Fraud

  • Hallucination

  • Or a desperate attempt for control

So why does that logic disappear when Muhammad makes the same claim?


🧠 Let’s Lay It Out Logically

🔹 Premise 1:

Truth claims that depend entirely on private experiences are unverifiable.

🔹 Premise 2:

The Qur’an’s revelations were all private — no witnesses, no collaborative confirmations.

🔹 Premise 3:

Unverifiable claims are not sufficient to prove divine origin.

✅ Conclusion:

The Qur’an is based on hearsay, not revelation.
And Islam stands on a foundation no one saw happen.


📉 A Prophet With No Public Revelation?

Compare this to the biblical pattern:

  • Moses received revelation in front of the nation — 600,000 witnesses at Sinai.

  • Jesus taught publicly, performed signs publicly, was crucified publicly.

  • Isaiah, Elijah, John the Baptist — all spoke openly, performed publicly, were held accountable.

But Muhammad?

  • Receives "revelation" in a cave, alone.

  • Says Jibril appears, but no one else sees him.

  • Recites words — then modifies, abrogates, or forgets them later.

That’s not the pattern of a prophet. That’s the pattern of a man in total control of the narrative.


🗣 But What About the Companions?

Apologists will say:

“But Muhammad’s companions believed him!”

Sure — and so do cult followers today. Belief proves nothing.
Especially when that belief was:

  • Based on fear, not facts,

  • Reinforced through war, loot, and marriages to consolidate power,

  • And structured to benefit Muhammad personally (e.g., special privileges in Surah 33:50).


📌 The Real Problem

Islam is based on:

  • An invisible angel

  • Speaking inaudible words

  • To one man

  • Behind closed doors

And from this private, unverifiable experience, we’re expected to accept:

  • A new religion

  • The cancellation of all previous scriptures

  • And obedience to a text compiled after that man’s death

That’s not revelation.
That’s a trust-me religion built on blind faith and zero evidence.


💣 Final Verdict

If no one saw the angel,
If no one heard the words,
If no one verified the revelation...

Then the Qur’an has no more credibility than someone saying,

“God talks to me in dreams — just believe me.”

Islam isn’t built on revelation.
It’s built on one man’s private claim, accepted without question and defended with fear.


💬 Mic-Drop Closer

“A real prophet stands before the people.
Muhammad stood alone — and said, ‘Believe me, or else.’
That’s not divine authority. That’s religious monopoly with no witnesses.”

No comments:

Post a Comment

  Islam’s Preservation Dilemma: Why the Qur'an Self-Destructs Introduction Islam claims to be the final, perfect revelation of the God o...